Why do so many people fear public speaking? - the 'spotlight effect' and other explanations

With Halloween upon us, I thought it was timely to look at why a fear of public speaking is so common! 

My Toastmasters Club, Talking Heads, has a Mark Twain quote on our website, "There are two types of speakers - those that are nervous and those that are liars". 

​You have probably seen headlines reporting surveys showing that people fear public speaking more than death, and you may be familiar with the Jerry Seinfeld quote:
“According to most studies, people's number one fear is public speaking. Number two is death. Death is number two. Does that sound right? This means to the average person, if you go to a funeral, you're better off in the casket than doing the eulogy.”

Of course, Jerry Seinfeld is really highlighting that it is silly to believe that people fear public speaking more than death. I am not the first person to point out that if you held a gun to someone’s head and told them to speak, they would be quick to oblige!

 I am not going to quote statistics here because they are contradictory and I am sure they are influenced by how questions are framed. Nevertheless, I know for a fact that a fear of public speaking is very common because I have met so many people who share the same fear I once had.

There are a number of theories about why we fear public speaking. Most of these theories are not mutually exclusive.

Evolutionary basis
A fear of public speaking may have an evolutionary basis. When we get really nervous it triggers a fight-flight-freeze response. See this article for a good explanation of “freeze” which is typically what happens to us in public speaking. These are all responses which can aid survival in the face of danger. But why would we perceive public speaking as dangerous?!

I have seen a couple of different explanations for this:

• When we are standing on a stage we feel exposed. The audience are the ‘predators’, we are in the spotlight, and there is no barrier between us and danger!
• When we are on the stage we are separated from the group. Once upon a time being ostracized or rejected by the group meant certain death as we had no protection. (https://www.psychologytoday.com/au/blog/the-real-story-risk/201211/the-thing-we-fear-more-death)

These theories might seem far-fetched, but there is no doubt that a fear of public speaking can invoke an intense physical response and so I think it is credible to assume that there is an evolutionary basis.

Fear of being judged
I survey my course participants before they start the course, and a common concern they have is looking nervous because it makes them feel weak or self-conscious.

In my experience people almost always feel more nervous than they look. I have a blog article coming soon on this topic. And even if I can tell someone is nervous, that is just a sign to me that they care!

The other thing to remember is that you are probably being judged less than you think. Most of us feel a bit self-conscious when the attention is focused on us. But the Spotlight Effect is a cognitive bias which describes the tendency to overestimate how much other people notice how you look and act. As an audience member you probably form some judgements of a speaker but you are more focused on what they are saying and what is in it for you. Or you may even be thinking about other things! The point is that we overestimate how much attention people are really paying to us as a speaker. For an excellent discussion of how the spotlight effect relates to public speaking see this article. 

Self-defeating thoughts
Another set of theories focus on how our negative or self-defeating thoughts can fuel a fear of public speaking. Some of these include:

• A tendency to focus on the negative or remember only our mistakes after giving a speech or presentation. We are experts at dismissing the positive and paying too much attention to mistakes which were probably only noticeable (or at least memorable) to ourselves! See my previous blog article on this. 
• Fear of a past bad experience being repeated. If we have one bad experience of public speaking it can rattle us and make us worry that it will happen again. A neuroscientist and author of Buddha’s Brain, Dr Rick Hansen says, ‘Our brains are like Teflon for negative experiences and Velcro for positive experiences.’ 
• Fear of fear – we worry about how our nervousness will affect our performance. While it is true that extreme nervousness is likely to undermine our performance, a few nerves can actually be helpful as I explain in this article. 

Confusing fear with excitment 
This theory suggests that initial physical reactions to public speaking are not about fear but are merely the result of our bodies preparing to perform.  This theory fits with the idea that a little nervous energy will enhance our performance. Fear and excitement are closely related and produce similar reactions in our body. Think of an athlete on the start line of an important race – they will feel a mix of excitement and nerves which in turn produces the adrenalin needed to run fast!
​
When it comes to public speaking, this adrenalin can also be helpful in small doses.  But if our brain interprets our feelings as fear instead of excitement or anticipation, this produces a more severe physical response which is unhelpful.  

​Genetics
This is not a separate theory but helps explain why some people seem to react to stressful situations than others. Highly anxious people appear to be prone to produce more cortisol under stress than the average person.
 
Notice that these theories have something in common – the fear is out of proportion to the ‘danger’. Of course, we already know this. Like any phobia, Glossophobia, another term for fear of public speaking, is not rationale.  But knowing this doesn’t reduce the fear! On the other hand, I strongly believe that having some understanding of what is behind our fear and knowing that others share this fear is a good first step to addressing it. 

Article written by Catherine Syme 

Enjoyed this article? Fear-less is developing an online course that you can do in your own time. It is for people with a fear of public speaking who want to increase their confidence and competence, and who are unable or not ready to attend a public speaking course. It includes videos, training materials, and daily speaking exercises that will help prepare you for speaking to an audience. It will be available in 2021. Please email admin@fear-less.co.nz to register your interest.